Accused against judge hearing case

February 23, 2011 (Page 3 lead)

TWO of the three soldiers who have been accused of murdering Alhaji Issa Mobilla are praying the Supreme Court to prohibit the trial judge from further hearing their case at the Fast Track High Court.
Mr Thaddeus Sory, counsel for Corporal Yaw Appiah and Private Eric Modzaka, is praying the highest court of the land to prohibit Mr Justice Senyo Dzamefe from presiding over the trial of his clients on the grounds that he does not have the mandate from the Chief Justice to further hear the case.
The matter was adjourned sine die at the Supreme Court yesterday because a representative from the Attorney-General's office told the court that a Chief State Attorney in charge of the case, Ms Penelope Marmattah, was indisposed.
The court, presided over by Ms Justice Sophia Akuffo, accordingly adjourned the case and urged parties in the case to liaise with the Registrar of the Supreme Court for a new date.
It also indicated that it would expect a representative from the Attorney-General's office to argue the case of the state, whether or not Ms Marmattah was present on the next adjourned date.
In the substantive motion, the soldiers are praying the court to prohibit the trial judge on the grounds that because he had no mandate, his continuous hearing of the case will be unconstitutional.
According to the applicants, the trial judge had also exhibited bias against them and for that reason they could not be guaranteed a fair trial.
Meanwhile, the substantive case at the Fast Track High Court has been adjourned to March 24, 2011.
Appiah and Modzaka have pleaded not guilty to two counts of conspiracy and murder.
Their alleged accomplice, Private Seth Goka, is currently on the run and is being tried in absentia.
The three were alleged to have murdered Alhaji Mobilla, who was the Northern Regional Chairman of the Convention People’s Party (CPP), on December 9, 2004.
Mr Justice Dzamefe, a Court of Appeal judge sitting with additional responsibility as a High Court judge, had, on December 7, 2010, directed the prosecution and the defence teams to file their addresses on whether the trial should continue or start afresh following the recovery of the foreman of the seven-member jury who had suffered a stroke in the course of the trial.
The foreman, who had been replaced with another juror, recuperated before the trial resumed and for that reason Ms Marmattah prayed the court to continue hearing the case, but Mr Sory objected to the continuation of the case and prayed the court to start hearing it afresh.
The trial judge was also expected to decide whether or not he would continue hearing the matter, following an objection from Mr Sory who prayed the judge to step aside following his promotion to the Court of Appeal.
According to Mr Sory, the judge had failed to produce any document to prove that the Chief Justice had appointed him (trial judge) to hear the matter afresh.
The facts of the case are that Alhaji Mobilla was arrested by the police on December 9, 2004 for allegedly supplying the youth in Tamale with guns to foment trouble.
While he was in custody, the police claimed that they received information that his followers and sympathisers were mobilising to free him. The deceased was consequently transferred from police cells to the Kamina Military Barracks and handed over to the three accused persons.
According to the prosecution, Alhaji Mobila died in military custody three hours after he had been handed over to the accused persons who were on duty that day.
The chief pathologist’s report revealed that the deceased was sent to the hospital dead and that he died from multiple wounds.